Use this 7 point thrift store test to spot worthwhile farmhouse finds, avoid costly mistakes and choose your finds wisely.
Hello, my wonderful friends! Today is Farmhouse Thrift Store Makeover Day, but we are doing things a little differently. Instead of simply looking at beautiful transformations, I thought we could talk about something every thrifter has probably wondered while standing in an aisle with a questionable piece in front of them…
Should I buy this… or should I put it back?
That can be a surprisingly difficult decision. Sometimes we see so much potential in a piece that we forget to look closely at what we are actually bringing home. Other times, we walk away from something wonderful because it looks worn, dated or completely hopeless at first glance.
The truth is that not every thrift store find is a hidden treasure. Some pieces are going to require more time, money, tools and patience than we have available. There is absolutely nothing wrong with admitting that. A bargain is only a bargain when you can realistically complete the project and use the finished piece.
On the other hand, scratches, tired finishes and missing pieces do not always mean something should be left behind. With a little imagination and the right plan, an overlooked find can become something beautiful, useful and completely unique.
That is why I put together this simple 7 Point Thrift Store Test. I hope it helps you slow down, look beyond the price tag and make better decisions before your next treasure comes home with you.
Print the 7 Point Thrift Store Test
Keep this simple little test nearby before your next thrifting trip so you can slow down, look carefully and choose the pieces that are truly worth bringing home.
Download the 7 Point TestJOIN THE COTTAGE MARKET FAMILY
A Little Cottage Inspiration in Your Inbox
Join us for free printables, cozy decorating ideas, easy DIY projects, delicious recipes and plenty of happy inspiration!
Slow Down Before You Buy
The 7 Point Thrift Store Test
1. Look at the Material and Construction
Before you think about paint colors or where a piece might go, take a close look at what it is made from. Solid wood, quality veneer, sturdy metal and tightly woven baskets can often be cleaned, repaired and enjoyed for many more years. Open drawers, check joints, gently wiggle the piece and look underneath whenever possible. A worn finish is usually manageable. Weak construction, crumbling particleboard or serious structural damage may be another story.2. Inspect the Damage Honestly
Scratches, loose knobs, small holes and tired paint are usually easier to handle than they appear. Broken legs, deep cracks, widespread wood rot and major warping can require considerably more work. Ask yourself whether the damage is decorative or structural. Then be honest about your skills, tools and available time. There is no shame in putting a piece back when the repairs are beyond what you want to tackle. Knowing when to walk away is part of becoming a smart and successful thrifter.3. Give It the Smell Test
This is not the most glamorous thrifting tip, but it is one of the most important. Open drawers, lift lids and smell inside upholstered pieces, cabinets, baskets and wooden furniture. Smoke, mildew, pet odors and dampness can soak deeply into certain materials. Some smells can be removed with cleaning, sanding and fresh air. Others seem determined to stay forever. When an odor is very strong, think carefully before bringing the item into your home.4. Consider How It Will Be Cleaned
Almost every secondhand piece needs a thorough cleaning, but some items are much easier to clean safely than others. Think about the material and whether it can be washed, scrubbed, vacuumed, sanded or disinfected. Be especially careful with upholstered furniture, heavily soiled baskets and anything showing signs of moisture or pests. A dirty surface should not automatically scare you away… but you should have a realistic cleaning plan before you buy.5. Know Where You Will Use It
It is easy to fall in love with a charming basket, stool or cabinet simply because it is inexpensive. Unfortunately, inexpensive treasures can still become clutter when we have no real purpose for them. Before you head to the register, try to name the room and the job the piece will have. Will it provide storage? Become a side table? Hold towels? Display flowers? Fill an empty wall? You do not need every detail figured out, but having a general purpose can prevent a bargain from spending the next three years waiting in the garage.6. Decide Whether to Paint, Restore or Leave It Alone
Paint can completely transform an ordinary piece, but not everything needs to be painted. Beautiful wood grain, original hardware, old labels and naturally aged finishes may be worth preserving. Other pieces have wonderful shapes but finishes that are damaged, dated or simply not right for your home. Pause before reaching for the paintbrush. Ask whether paint will improve the piece or cover something that makes it special. Sometimes the best answer is paint. Sometimes it is stain, oil or a gentle cleaning. Sometimes the original finish deserves to remain exactly as it is.7. Calculate the True Cost
The thrift store price is only the beginning. Add the cost of paint, primer, hardware, wood filler, sandpaper, replacement parts and any tools you might need. Then consider the value of your time. A $10 dresser can still be an incredible bargain, even after purchasing supplies, when it is solid and useful. A badly damaged $10 table can become an expensive headache if it requires materials and equipment you will never use again. The goal is not always to spend the smallest amount possible. The goal is to spend wisely on pieces that are worth your effort. Now let us look at five amazing transformations that put different parts of this test into action.The Test in Action
Five Thrift Store Makeovers Worth Studying
A Cabinet Door Becomes a Cottage Farmhouse Shelf
Starting Cost: $1.99 for the cabinet door, plus salvaged materials
At first glance, an old cabinet door and a discarded bed rail might not look like the beginning of anything special. Christy saw beyond the individual pieces and turned them into a charming Cottage Farmhouse shelf complete with handmade brackets, hooks, a pretty transfer and delightful library inspired labels. This makeover is a wonderful reminder that the original purpose of an item does not have to determine its future. Look at the shape, material and construction… then let your imagination take over. Not every piece of scrap wood is worth saving, but sturdy materials and a creative vision can produce a truly remarkable transformation. Source
A $10 Waterfall Dresser Gets a Beautiful New Beginning
Starting Cost: $10
This solid Waterfall dresser had wonderful original hardware and plenty of character, but its top drawers did not close correctly. Denise cleaned the piece, repaired the worn drawer guides, carefully prepared the veneer and used one beautiful paint color to give it a rich new look. This project demonstrates why we need to inspect damage before buying. The drawer problem was repairable, but it still required tools, patience and the willingness to learn a new technique. Ask yourself honestly whether you are excited to make those repairs. When the answer is yes, a forgotten $10 dresser can become an extraordinary piece of furniture. When the answer is no, it is perfectly fine to walk away. Source
An Old Step Ladder Becomes a Useful Side Table
Starting Cost: Pieces gathered from the project stash
An old step ladder and a thrifted cutting board may seem like two completely unrelated finds, but together they became a unique and practical side table. The cutting board was sanded and sealed, then securely attached to the ladder with carefully selected wood screws. This is a wonderful example of looking at the shape of an item rather than its original job. It also shows that every makeover does not have to become a major restoration. With cleaning, sanding, paint, stain and a little simple construction, two forgotten pieces can become something useful in a manageable weekend project. Source
A Free Curbside Table With a Warped Top
Starting Cost: Free
This ornate table was discovered on the curb, but once Denise brought it home, she realized it was in much worse condition than she first thought. It had peeling veneer, broken trim, wood rot and a severely warped top. Rather than pretending this was an easy project, she turned it into a valuable lesson. She experimented with moisture, weight, heat and patience to improve the warped wood. The finished top was not perfectly level, and I love the honesty of that result. Not every makeover ends in perfection. This project teaches us to inspect a piece carefully and accept that some repairs are experiments. You may create something beautiful and learn an incredible amount, but you also need to decide whether you are comfortable with an imperfect result. Sometimes saving a piece is worth it for the experience… even when it does not become something you would sell. Source
A $50 Thrifted Blanket Box With Lasting Quality
Starting Cost: $50 after a 50 percent discount
This blanket box originally carried a $100 price tag, so Denise patiently watched it until the thrift store marked it down by half. Once she brought it home, a preserved maker’s label and the overall construction confirmed that she had purchased a quality piece. The exterior was worn, but the box itself was in good condition. Denise cleaned it thoroughly, removed the old lock for safety, sanded the finish and gave it a handsome new look while preserving many of its best features. This is such a good lesson because thrift store shopping is not always about buying the least expensive item in the building. Sometimes paying a little more for a solid, well constructed piece is the wiser choice. Research the maker, examine the construction, watch for sale days and never be afraid to politely ask whether there is any flexibility in the price. A piece like this could provide storage for decades and may eventually be handed down with a wonderful story attached to it. SourceBefore You Head to the Register…
Take one final moment and ask yourself:- Is it made well?
- Can I handle the repairs?
- Can it be cleaned safely?
- Do I know where I will use it?
- Will I paint it, restore it or preserve it?
- What will the entire project really cost?
- Am I genuinely excited to work on it?
Keep the Inspiration Going
Explore More Crafts, Cozy Roundups and Creative Ideas
There is always something new to discover here at The Cottage Market! Browse easy crafts, clever DIY projects, inspiring makeovers, cozy decorating ideas, helpful tips, delicious vegetarian recipes and all of our newest weekly roundups.
Browse DIY and Craft Ideas Explore All RoundupsVisit Your Favorite Cottage Market Corners
Do Not Miss the Freebies
More Than 4,000 Free Printables Are Waiting for You!
Print a little happiness for your home! Explore free wall art, planners, recipe cards, banners, seasonal favorites, digital papers and so much more. New printables are added regularly, so there is always something lovely waiting to be discovered.
Browse All Free Printables See Today’s Free Printable
New crafts, roundups, makeovers, recipes, helpful ideas and free printables are added every week… so be sure to come back and visit again soon!
Want to stay in the know? I’d really love that!
Come say hello and follow along for more cozy inspiration, creative crafts, free printables, thrift store treasures, easy recipes and a little everyday cottage charm…
Facebook  |  Pinterest  |  Instagram
Sending you lots of love and the biggest (((HUGS)))
Leave a Reply